Page 6 of the Shippensburg Area School District's 2026-27 final budget has two tax rates next to each other. Property on the Cumberland County side of the district pays 14.7634 mills. Property on the Franklin County side pays 137.0006 mills. Shippensburg Borough sits in both counties, so a buyer comparing two homes a few blocks apart can find one rate is more than nine times the other.
That gap tells you very little about which house costs more to own. The district's own budget shows how the rates are built. At the district level, the two sides pay the same school levy per dollar of state-estimated market value. What the county line really decides is the yardstick used to measure a home's value. On the Franklin side, that yardstick hasn't been reset since 1961, and a reassessment push that Shippensburg Borough Council just joined is aimed at it.
Two counties, two yardsticks
The millage only means something once you know what it's multiplied against. Cumberland County's last reassessment valued property as of January 1, 2010, and those values took effect in 2011. Franklin County's assessment office says its assessments represent 100% of 1961 market value, and 1961 was the year its last countywide reassessment took effect.
The district's 2026-27 budget shows how far apart those yardsticks have drifted.
| Shippensburg Area SD, 2026-27 | Cumberland side | Franklin side |
|---|---|---|
| Assessment base | Jan. 1, 2010 values, effective 2011 | 1961 values |
| Total assessed value | $1,499,853,500 | $118,694,740 |
| 2024 state market value estimate | $1,410,097,899 | $1,035,540,561 |
| Share of district market value | 57.66% | 42.34% |
| School levy needed | $22,142,987 | $16,261,255 |
| School tax rate | 14.7634 mills | 137.0006 mills |
The Franklin side holds about 42% of the district's market value but only about 7% of its assessed value. On the Cumberland side, assessed value and the state's market estimate are close to each other. On the Franklin side, total assessed value is roughly one-ninth of the market estimate, and that is about the same ratio as the two tax rates.
Now divide each side's levy by its market value. Cumberland's $22.1 million against $1.41 billion and Franklin's $16.3 million against $1.04 billion both come out to about 1.57% of state-estimated market value. That equality is designed in. The two rates are set so that, at the district level, the school levy per dollar of state-estimated market value is about the same in either county.
How the district splits the bill across the line
Districts that cross county lines divide their tax levy under Section 672.1 of the Pennsylvania School Code. Shippensburg Area's budget shows the steps.
- Take the prior year's total levy, $36,458,028 for 2025-26.
- Divide it between the counties by each county's share of district market value, using the state's 2024 market value estimates.
- Turn each county's share into a base millage, then apply the Act 1 index, which was 4.7% this year.
- Set each county's 2026-27 rate high enough to raise its share of the new levy.
Step two is where this year's story happens. Under last year's rates, the Franklin side produced $14,567,008 of the levy. Once the split was recalculated on the state's 2024 market value estimates, the Franklin side's share rose to $15,437,182 before any new revenue was added. That moved about $870,000 of the existing burden across the county line.
The budget's comparison page shows the result. Measured against the rebalanced prior-year rates, the Cumberland-side rate went down 0.10%, from 14.7811 to 14.7634 mills. The Franklin-side rate went up 4.70%, from 130.8507 to 137.0006 mills, which is exactly the Act 1 index cap for that county. The dollar levy went up on both sides, from $21,020,846 to $22,142,987 on the Cumberland side and from $15,437,182 to $16,261,255 on the Franklin side. The Cumberland-side rate could still drop slightly because its assessed value base grew, from $1,481,014,300 to $1,499,853,500. The Franklin-side rate went to the cap.
For a buyer, this means the Franklin-side rate can move for reasons unrelated to the district's spending. It depends on each county's share of the state's market value estimates, which is what the district uses to rebalance the levy.
Assessments on each side of the county line
On the Cumberland side, a 2010 assessment is 16 years old. On the Franklin side, a 1961-based assessment has to cover more than six decades of additions, renovations, and neighborhood change. The state's common level ratios show the distance. The State Tax Equalization Board certified a 63.9% ratio for Cumberland County and 7.2% for Franklin County, effective July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027. Pennsylvania's Department of Revenue publishes a separate set of factors for realty transfer tax. The ratio is a median of assessment-to-sale-price ratios from valid sales. As a rough picture, though, a median of about 7 cents of assessed value per dollar of sale price leaves a lot of room for individual homes to fall above or below it.
The homestead exclusion follows the same pattern. The district's budget lists homestead exclusions of $17,837 of assessed value on the Cumberland side and $2,135 on the Franklin side. Multiplied by each side's 2026-27 rate, that comes to about $263 on the Cumberland side and about $292 on the Franklin side. The exclusion amounts look very different, but the dollar amounts are close.
The reassessment push now includes Shippensburg
Franklin County's 1961 base is now a live fight. On Sept. 14, 2026, Chambersburg Town Council voted 9-1 to hire Knox Law of Erie as special counsel, and the Chambersburg Public Opinion reported that the firm will prepare documents and exhibits for possible legal action to require a countywide reassessment. Speaking to FOX43, council member David Wilson said the commissioners had indicated they would not reassess unless the state set a required schedule or a court ordered it. The commissioners told the station: "The Franklin County Commissioners affirm that reassessment is not indicated. The county will defend its approach and stand by any court decision." Earlier in the year, ABC27 reported that the commissioners supported a mandatory statewide reassessment schedule and had raised the issue with state legislators.
According to the Shippensburg News-Chronicle, Shippensburg Borough Council has approved its own agreement with Knox Law to join the effort. Chambersburg Borough pays all legal fees and costs under the agreement, and other participating municipalities may contribute but aren't required to. Borough officials planned to ask the Shippensburg Area School Board to participate at its Oct. 26 meeting. The board's minutes from that meeting will show the district's decision.
The district already splits its levy between counties using the state's market value estimates, not assessed values. For now, any reassessment is a possibility, not a schedule.
The other line items that follow the same line
County and municipal taxes also change at the line, and they use the same two yardsticks. Cumberland County's 2026 rate sheet lists 2.875 mills for the county, 3.249 mills for Shippensburg Borough, 1.150 mills for Shippensburg Township, and 0.250 mills for Southampton Township. Franklin County's proposed 2026 budget announcement kept the county rate at 29.1 mills, made up of 25.0 mills for operations and 4.1 mills for debt service. The two county rates measure different bases, so the 29.1-mill figure can't be compared with the 2.875-mill figure any more than the school rates can.
Transfer tax at closing works differently. Pennsylvania's state realty transfer tax is 1%. The school district lists a 0.5% transfer tax for 2026-27. Shippensburg Borough Council minutes from November 2024 list a 0.5% borough transfer tax.
This is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Before you make an offer, confirm the assessment, millage, and transfer tax for the specific parcel with the county assessment office, the school district, and your own tax professional.
FAQ
How do the two sides compare at the district level? Both sides pay about the same school levy per dollar of the state's market value estimate. On the Franklin side, assessments are based on 1961 values.
Why did the Franklin-side school rate rise 4.70% this year? Rebalancing on the state's market value estimates moved about $870,000 of the existing levy to the Franklin side before the Act 1 index increase was applied. The Cumberland-side rate went down 0.10% over the same period.
Has a reassessment lawsuit been filed? Chambersburg and Shippensburg boroughs have engaged Knox Law, and Franklin County's commissioners have said they will defend their approach. Check current local coverage before treating any reassessment timeline as settled.
At Lisa Mack, we look at the assessment behind any Shippensburg home we price, especially on the Franklin side. If you own on either side of the county line and want to know how your home's market value compares with what you're taxed on, Request a Free Home Valuation and we'll go through the numbers with you.